comments 5

Libby’s Story: How I Quit Added Sugar

It started innocently enough. As a new mom of two, I’d packed on some extra pounds. Suddenly, I started feeling sluggish. My memory was off. My emotions? All over the place. I chalked it up to late nights with a baby and powered through as best I could.

Then one morning, I noticed that the back of my neck looked dirty. Worse, the “dirt” wouldn’t rub off. I got worried and called my doctor. She ran some tests which showed I was on the cusp of prediabetes. My blood sugar levels were spiking, and that could harm my long-term health.

I’ve been technically obese for years, but my “health numbers” had always been great — until now. It seemed those last few pounds may have been the tipping point.

I was determined to take back control of my health numbers.

The doughnut question

Soon after, a colleague brought doughnuts into a meeting — and they looked delicious.

But I’d also been reading about sugar’s effects on health. Today, scientists and pundits assert many points of view, from “Sugar is poison” to “It’s fine in moderation.” The wide range of arguments reminded me of the early debates around tobacco use.

Taking a doughnut from the box, I joked to my co-workers, “Is sugar the new smoking? Will we one day look back and think, how could they bring all of those sweets to the office?”

That’s when I decided to try an experiment:

What would my health – and life – be like without added sugar?


As an ex-smoker, I knew I couldn’t just quit sugar cold turkey. I’d need some substitutes. So I laid out the ground rules and stocked my cabinets.

  • First: I wasn’t going to reduce calories and quit sugar simultaneously. For me, that would’ve meant instant failure. So I gave myself permission to eat as much as my body told me it needed during this time.
  • I also decided that I could eat as much natural sugar as I wanted, but it had to be from whole foods. Fruit? Unlimited. Fruit juice? Not so much. That’s because research shows the fiber in an orange produces a lower insulin spike than when you throw back a glass of OJ.
  • I also gave myself an occasional out: I could have one serving of an added-sugar food like birthday cake on set special occasions.

The first few weeks

It felt like there weren’t enough carbohydrates on earth to satisfy my needs. I was surprised at how much my body craved pasta, potatoes and other foods that mimic refined sugar — and increase insulin production during digestion. I wasn’t giving up carbs, though, so I let myself have them. It was delicious and a little odd. My husband questioned why I suddenly wanted spaghetti for breakfast.

Eventually, the carbohydrate cravings leveled off. And, after that, it was surprisingly easy to leave the sugar alone.

A few months in

About three months into this experience, I realized that my pants weren’t fitting, but in the best of ways. Without changing anything else about my diet, I lost 10 pounds. This told me that I had no idea how much refined sugar I’d been eating.

I also entered into “candy season” — September through January — when many of my family’s birthdays occur, plus all the feasting holidays. After a summer being relatively sugar-free, this part of the experiment was both super-difficult and eye-opening.

As I enjoyed my “allowed” slice of birthday cake, suddenly, sugar tasted different to me. Too much started to taste bad.

My first real slip-up involved a deliberate donut shop run. I ordered a latte and some tasty treats. My first sip tasted terrible. It was just a wall of syrupy sweetness. Of course, I took another sip, just to be sure. The same result.

I ended up throwing the whole “naughty treat” away. Cheating wasn’t fun because my tastes had changed.

What I learned

Ultimately, I phased out my sugar experiment. Why? Because I found out what I needed to know. For me, added sugar really does make an impact on health. I was eating way too much of it, and I could enjoy a lot less of it — if I choose my treats more carefully.

Today, I’m watching calories, carbohydrates, refined sugar and portion sizes through a popular app. I’m also attending free weight-management seminars at work, as part of the BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee employee wellness program.

So far, I’ve lost about 35 pounds. My blood sugar has returned to normal levels, and my doctor and I are high-fiving about my health turnaround.

Most importantly, my energy levels, memory and emotions are back to normal. And, I value my health a lot differently now, too. Being healthy is the most important way I can ensure I’ll enjoy my family, friends and career for years to come.

3 sweet steps to consider if you want to reduce added sugar

1. Find motivation

Fitting into new clothes may be fun, but you may be more successful by aiming for a deeper motivation that speaks to better health or connecting with others.

2. Make a realistic plan

Big changes can be made with small steps. Set yourself up for success by making one adjustment at a time.

3. Look for lessons

You may be surprised by what you learn; consider writing your thoughts down so you’ll remember your results.

Libby Clark

Libby Clark

Libby joined the BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee corporate communications team in 2016. A Chattanooga native, she has nearly 20 years of experience in writing about corporate culture. Outside work, she enjoys spending time with her family and traveling to interesting places as often as possible.

More Posts

BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee members can access wellness-related discounts on fitness products, gym memberships, healthy eating and more through Blue365®. BCBST members can also use tools and resources to help improve health and well-being by logging into BlueAccess and going to the in the Member Wellness Center under the Managing Your Health tab.

Filed under: Food & Recipes, Real Stories


Libby Clark

Libby joined the BlueCross BlueShield of Tennessee corporate communications team in 2016. A Chattanooga native, she has nearly 20 years of experience in writing about corporate culture. Outside work, she enjoys spending time with her family and traveling to interesting places as often as possible.


  1. Avatar
    Marcia says

    Thanks for a great article! Sugar is definitely my nemesis.

  2. Avatar
    Elizabeth Brannon says

    My workplace for five years in my 40s when the pounds start sneaking on was a real detriment to my health: pastor’s secretary at my home church. Well-meaning members would drop goodies by for the staff way too often. Then I went home to cook for my Mississippi-native husband born with a sweet tooth but blessed with a great metabolism. Both situations together and I gained some 30 pounds over my normal weight. Now at 74 and living in rural Tennessee, I am often the odd woman out among my contemporaries. I lost nearly 35 pounds, most of it in 2012 and wear the same size as 50 years ago. Sugar is not anyone’s friend, nor is an excess of carbs. All retired folks seem to want to do is eat out. Go to a pot luck or even congregate dining at the senior center and what passes for healthy is shocking. Socialize instead by a walk in the park or a swim at the local pool. The main thing is keep moving, with the exception being silverware in the direction of your mouth. I’d rather have to tell people as I did recently that I fractured ribs falling down a hillside at the park on the way back to my car AFTER a four-mile hike as I did two months ago than be the elderly woman I met who broke her leg getting out of her recliner. I would already have had knee-replacement surgeries had I not lost the weight and would probably be diabetic besides. Now if I could just rearrange the effects of gravity on the 140 pounds I have left! ?

  3. Avatar
    Latoya Cox says

    Thank you for this article, Libby! Great job sticking to it and for sharing your findings with us. I am trying to cut sugar and this was just the added motivation needed.

  4. Avatar

    I felt inspired by Libby’s Story. I’m going to try her stratergy with reducing sugar intake. Thanks for the inspiration.

WellTuned provides inspiration and practical advice for healthy living.
WellTuned does not offer medical advice. Any personal health questions should be addressed to your doctor.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *